-
The Babymaker (Part 2)
Date: 9/22/2015, Categories: First Time, Taboo, Voyeur, Author: brianbigdogsmith, Rating: 90, Source: xHamster
"Yeah," I nodded into the phone. "I promise." "Ummmm...How many guesses do I get?" "Just one!" I laughed. "That's not fair!" "Yeah it is." "How about two guesses?" "No way!" "Then you gotta be my boyfriend, right?" "You don't even know what Angie gave me." "Just promise me!" "I got a girlfriend," I sighed. "I told you like ten times already." "So? Is it a bet or what?" "We already have a bet!" "Yeah, but now I only get one guess..." "So?" "...so you gotta make it worth it," she said seriously. "Are you gonna be my boyfriend?" "I...can't. I mean..." "If I guess it right, you gotta be my boyfriend." "Why?" I bit my lip because win or lose, Stacy was gonna let me pop her cherry. God! But being her boyfriend... "I never did it before. I don't wanna do it with somebody else's boyfriend. That would suck!" "Yeah. I guess it would," I shrugged, but this whole thing was really strange. "If you're not my boyfriend..." Stacy sighed, "...I don't think I we can do it." "We can't?" My dick was hard just thinking about knocking Angie up...or her twin s****r. Like, what was the difference? "Nope...So, we got a deal or what?" "Yeah," I laughed, feeling kind of crazy. "I'll be your boyfriend if you're right." "If we do it, you mean." "No, just ... if you guess right," I said, thinking I was pretty smart. She couldn't outfox me! "If you're wrong, we'll still do it, but I'm not gonna be your boyfriend." "That's not fair!" "That's what you said before." "Yeah, but..." "Is it a deal?" I asked her. "Or what?" "Yeah, okay," Stacy sighed. "But if we do it and you're not my boyfriend, I'm not gonna like you." "Okay. Whatever," I rolled my eyes. "Guess." "I'm thinking! Don't rush me!" "Dah-de-dum-dum..." I started doing the Jeopardy song for her. "Was it ummmm..." Stacy was quiet for three seconds. "You don't know." "...a bubblegum wrapper with my phone number on it?" "What?" I almost dropped the phone. "Ha!" she laughed. "Hey boyfriend!" "Angie?" "Noooo..." she giggled, "...but you can call me Angie sometimes, if you want to. I like it." "That was you, Stacy? At the mall?" "Yeah!" she giggled. "Angie had to go to a church thing with Mom on Sunday." "Julie didn't know?" "Nobody can tell. I told you that." "So why did you give me your phone number? What if I called Angie and..." "Asked for a favor?" Steph laughed. "That would have been pretty funny." "For you maybe," I frowned. "She does the same stuff to me." "She gives guys your name and phone number?" "Well...no, not ...