1. Amy Repays Her Friend, Cara


    Date: 7/30/2015, Categories: Cheating, Author: benawriter, Rating: 12, Source: LushStories

    Previously, Amy asked her friend Cara to help her prove or disprove that her boyfriend Roger was cheating on her. She sent her boyfriend to the shoe store where Cara works and asked Cara to try to seduce him, to see if he would remain faithful. When Amy mentioned the size of Roger’s cock, Cara became curious and then actually seduced Roger in the stockroom of the shoe store, but both swore they would never tell Cara. A few days later, Cara received a phone call from Amy. “I need to talk to you about Roger’s visit to your shoe store,” Amy said. “Can you come over tonight? It’s really important.” Cara feared that Roger may have disclosed their sexual union to Amy and she dreaded facing her. “Okay, I’ll be over after work,” Cara promised. But Cara called her twin sister, Tara. “Tara, I’m in a fix. I have a really hot date tonight with a guy and Amy wants me to come over. I think she found out I screwed Roger at the shoe store and she wants to confront me with it.” “What do you want me to do?” asked Tara. “Would you go over there for me, pretend to be me, and just apologize and see if you can keep my friendship with her?” “I suppose I could do that. I can take anything she throws at me, even if she thinks I’m you.” Said Tara. “Thanks; I appreciate it. I owe you one,” promised Cara. So Tara went to Amy’s house later that afternoon and discovered that the boyfriend was there. Amy was not hostile at all, but actually very friendly when Tara arrived. The three of them were sitting ...
    in the living room when Amy opened the conversation and nearly blew Tara away. “Cara, Roger told me that when he was in the store that you tried to seduce him, just as I asked, and I wanted him to know that I understood if he got aroused. I mean, it’s only natural for a guy to get hard when a girl goes to extremes to get him aroused. But he did admit that he was turned on and actually wanted to have sex with you and that’s why I asked you here today.” “What do you mean?” Tara asked, a little confused. “Well,” Amy continued, “I decided that if I let him fuck you with my approval that the appeal and curiosity for both of you about it would be satisfied and that would be the end of it. So, if I let him fuck you today, will you promise not to try to ever seduce him for real?” Tara smiled, knowing that she could answer honestly, “Yes, I promise, I’ll never approach him for sex ever again.” She said. “Okay, then, let’s get this over with,” Amy said with a sigh of relief. She led the way into her bedroom. They all undressed with no ceremony, but when Tara saw the girth of Roger’s cock her mouth dropped open in genuine surprise. “See, I told you that he had a big cock, didn’t I?” Amy asked. “Um, yeah, you did,” Tara answered. They climbed on the bed and as Roger lay down, Amy sat next to him and crossed her legs. “I’m going to watch you two and just masturbate, so just do whatever you feel like,” she said. Tara immediately took Roger’s fat member in her hands, amazed at how thick it ...
«12»